Robert Weis: Understanding the history of Life on Earth through fossils

As a collection manager and researcher at the MNHNL, Robert Weis dedicates his daily work to studying and preserving thousands of fossils – essential keys to understanding the evolution of life, major ecological crises, and contemporary environmental challenges. In this interview, he reflects on his unconventional career path, the importance of collaboration, the challenges of knowledge transmission, and the still underappreciated role of geoheritage in shaping our relationship with nature.

 

Can you explain your role at the MNHNL?

My main responsibility is managing the museum’s palaeontological collection. It contains more than 75,000 fossils. This involves organizing, preserving, documenting, and valorising these specimens.

 

Your career path is quite unusual…

After secondary school, I initially trained as a primary school teacher, but I quickly realized it was not the right path for me. I was already passionate about fossils and conducting my own research. I had even won the Jonk Fuerscher science competition with a palaeontology project.

At the time, I was already working at the museum as a student. When a position became available in 2002, I seized the opportunity. I trained largely through self-directed learning in palaeontology, collection management, and scientific research. This allowed me to develop an internationally recognized research profile, particularly on Jurassic cephalopods.

More recently, I obtained a master’s degree in Geosciences and Palaeontology from the University of Burgundy. In a way, my career developed in reverse: I gained experience before earning a final diploma.

 

How does one learn palaeontology outside a traditional academic path?

By immersing oneself in the work – and by surrounding oneself with the right people. I was fortunate to be guided by mentors, researchers, and university professors who shared their knowledge with me.

However, it also requires a great deal of personal initiative. You must seek out information, ask questions, read, and experiment. If you simply wait for opportunities to come to you, you won’t progress.

 

So, this passion goes back to childhood?

Absolutely. I started collecting fossils when I was about six years old. I found gryphaeas – very common fossils in Luxembourg – in fields and sorted them into boxes with labels.

Many children have this kind of curiosity, but it often fades with time. In my case, it never disappeared.

 

Your work also involves scientific research. What topics do you focus on?

I mainly work on Jurassic cephalopods – ammonites, belemnites, and nautiloids – a subject I have been exploring since the beginning of my career. Studying these fossils contributes to paleogeographic reconstructions, helps date geological strata (biostratigraphy), and improves our understanding of the evolution of these groups of marine invertebrates, whose distant descendants still inhabit today’s oceans.

My research is not limited to Luxembourg. I also work in France, Germany, and England. In fact, I will soon participate in excavations in Yorkshire to compare fossils found there with those discovered in Luxembourg.

In palaeontology, national borders are meaningless: during the Jurassic, all these territories formed part of the same marine environment. International collaboration is therefore essential.

 

What does managing a fossil collection involve in practice?

When a new collection arrives, the first step is sorting it. Around two-thirds of our specimens come from private collections. These may be donations, acquisitions, or contributions from amateur collectors and researchers. But not every specimen is retained; some have no scientific value.

The fossils are then cleaned, sometimes prepared by specialists, and documented. We gather all available information: where they were found, when they were discovered, their geological context, and who collected them. Without information about their origin and context, fossils lose much of their scientific value.

Each fossil receives a unique number, is entered into a database, labelled, and stored according to a precise system. It is very similar to managing a library. Finally, specimens are photographed and may become part of scientific research projects.

 

How do you decide what enters the collection?

This decision is made jointly with the curator, Ben Thuy. We assess the scientific value of each specimen. If a fossil is rare or provides new information, it is preserved. If we already have numerous similar examples, it may be excluded – unless it possesses a particular aesthetic or statistical interest.

Experience plays a key role in these decisions.

 

The museum also houses “holotypes.” Why are they important?

A holotype is the reference specimen used to describe a species. It is the specimen that officially defines that species in scientific literature. As such, it is unique and extremely valuable.

If a holotype is lost – as happened, for example, during the bombings of the Second World War – it creates a major problem. In such cases, a replacement specimen, known as a neotype, must be designated.

We currently house around 150 holotypes, and the number continues to grow. Today, many of them are being digitized in 3D, allowing researchers around the world to study them without travelling.

 

Are the collections accessible to the public?

They are not open to the general public, but researchers can access them upon request.

In our field, it is common to travel to different museums to study collections. Likewise, we regularly welcome foreign scientists who come to work with ours.

 

How is a collection of this size physically organized?

The collection is spread across two sites. Part of it is housed at the museum, in a storage area shared with the mineralogy department, allowing quick access to frequently used specimens. Larger or less frequently consulted pieces are stored in an external facility outside the city.

Over time, the collection has grown considerably – it has almost doubled in size over the past twenty years – which creates significant logistical challenges.

 

Collaboration between amateurs and scientists is essential in your field. Why?

It is fundamental. Much of our work relies on a network of scientific collaborators, many of whom are volunteers. Some take part in excavations, while others assist with sorting or identifying fossils.

This relationship of trust is extremely valuable because we know the origin of the collections and the reliability of the people who assembled them.

 

What do fossils teach us about the history of Luxembourg?

Our collection reflects the geological richness of the country. It includes Devonian fossils dating back around 400 million years, documenting the transition of life from marine to terrestrial environments, as well as Triassic and Jurassic fossils that mostly testify to an ancient marine past.

During the Jurassic, for example, Luxembourg was located on the margin of a vast marine basin known as the Paris Basin.

What is remarkable is the geological diversity concentrated within such a small territory. The north belongs to the Ardennes Massif, an ancient emergent landmass, while the centre and south were covered by the sea. This explains the diversity of rocks and fossils found across the country.

(Editor’s note: An emergent landmass is a portion of the Earth’s crust located above sea level. Saying that the Ardennes is an ancient emergent landmass means it remained above the sea for very long geological periods and is therefore composed of very ancient rocks.)

 

How can palaeontology help us understand today’s environmental challenges?

Together with other geosciences, palaeontology helps us understand the history of ecosystems and major biodiversity crises. For example, in Luxembourg we can study key periods such as the transition between the Triassic and Jurassic, marked by a significant extinction event.

Another particularly interesting example is the Toarcian period, during which atmospheric CO₂ levels increased, and ocean acidification occurred – phenomena comparable to those observed today. By studying these past events, we can better understand the mechanisms currently at work.

Is artificial intelligence changing the way you work?

Not significantly yet, but it could in the future. For example, we could imagine training AI systems to identify fossils from images. This would be particularly useful because there are fewer and fewer taxonomic specialists capable of making such identifications.

However, AI systems need to be trained on reliable data, which still depends on human expertise. Specialists are essential for producing and validating the knowledge on which these tools rely.

Today, many taxonomic experts are passionate self-taught specialists, often retired. Their knowledge is invaluable, but it risks being lost if it is not passed on to future generations.

 

How can we raise public awareness of these issues?

We need to transmit both knowledge and a sense of wonder. People protect what they know and what they love.

The museum contributes through exhibitions, workshops, and guided tours. This works particularly well with children, whose natural curiosity is still very much alive.

 

Which fossil has particularly impressed you?

A nautiloid that I described together with a colleague. We named it Cenoceras rumelangense, after the town of Rumelange.

To date, it is the largest fossil nautiloid ever discovered, reaching between 60 and 70 centimetres in diameter. Living nautiloids generally reach only about 20 centimetres!

 

You also work on the concept of geoheritage. What does that mean?

Geoheritage refers to geological elements – rocks, fossils, landscapes – that possess scientific, educational, or heritage value.

People often talk about biodiversity, but geodiversity is frequently overlooked. Yet it is an integral part of natural heritage. We are working to identify and promote geological sites in Luxembourg, notably with our partners in the Minett UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, the UNESCO Global Geopark Mëllerdall, and the Geological Survey of Luxembourg.

 

If you had unlimited resources, which project would you launch?

I would like to create a national inventory of geosites. And publish a high-quality illustrated book on Luxembourg’s most remarkable geological sites. It would be a wonderful way to promote this heritage and make it accessible to everyone.

 

Interview: Diane Bertel

Editors: Monique Kirsch (MNHNL), Selma Weber (MNHNL)